Home
reviews
album list

go to A go to B go to C go to D go to E go to F go to G go to H go to I go to J go to K go to L go to M go to N go to O go to P go to Q go to R go to S go to T go to U go to V go to W go to X go to Y go to Z go to numbers
go to Various Artists go to Possibles go to Mistaken ID go to Bootlegs go to Sampledelica

Ratings:
The * rating (½-5) is my personal, entirely subjective and completely partisan rating of the music.
There is, of course, no 'Tron rating.


Mangala Vallis
Manic Street Preachers
Jasun Martz
La Maschera di Cera
Mélia
Mellow
Mercury Rev
Metaphor
Mona Lisa
Moongarden
Neal Morse


Mangala Vallis  (Italy)

Mangala Vallis, 'Lycanthrope'

Lycanthrope  (2005,  62.17)  ***

Echo Absolute
Werewolf Suite:
  Cosmotraffic Jam
  Call Me Alias
  Lycanthroparty
  Hum/Animal Song
  The Boy That Howls at the Moon
  The Mask
  The Transparent and the Obscure

Current availability:

Mangala Vallis' first album, The Book of Dreams, features real Mellotron, although that's just about its only redeeming feature. However, their follow-up from three years later, Lycanthrope, proves that neo-proggers can improve, if only slightly. It starts off as a vast improvement on its predecessor, although it still opens with a Genesis steal (Watcher this time). Guest vocalist on their debut, ex-PFM man Bernardo Lanzetti, seems to've become a full member by this time, making Chocolate Kings comparisons inevitable; better than Script though, eh kids? Mangala Vallis' previous Spock's Beard influence seems to have become more dominant here, with the vast bulk of the hour-long album taken up by the sort-of title track, the Werewolf Suite, replete with loads of Enzo Cattini's Hammond and fake Mellotron work. Hurrah! This isn't to say it's all good, by any means; Lycanthroparty pumps away at a mainstream rock groove for far longer than necessary, including the obligatory dullsville guitar solo, and in fact, the quality dips as the album progresses, until by the end, it isn't an awful lot better than its predecessor. What a shame; if only the album had been shorter, maybe the band could've tightened up their arrangements and made for a better release all round. 'Tron samples across the board, mostly strings, with bits of flute and choir here and there, although some of the notes hold just that little bit too long.

So; a partly good partly non-neo-prog album with fake 'Tron. Concentrate on what makes the first half of Lycanthrope good, lads, and your third effort could be very reasonable. Incidentally, many thanks to my old pal Gary for extracting a sample use confession out of the band.

Official site

Manic Street Preachers  (UK)

Manic Street Preachers, 'This is My Truth Tell Me Yours'

This is My Truth Tell Me Yours  (1998)  ***

The Everlasting
If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next
You Stole the Sun From My Heart
Ready for Drowning
Tsunami
My Little Empire
I'm Not Working
You're Tender and You're Tired
Born a Girl
Be Natural
Black Dog on My Shoulder
Nobody Loved You
S.Y.M.M.

Current availability:

The Manic Street Preachers' story has been one of tragedy; their arch-propagandist, Richey James, disappeared in the mid-'90s, having almost certainly thrown himself off the Severn Bridge during a bad bout of depression. The band regrouped, recording Everything Must Go as soon as possible to try to overcome the trauma. In retrospect, Richey didn't seem to actually do an awful lot in the band, existing more as their public face than anything else, so their subsequent career hasn't suddenly taken a lurch in a different direction. The Manics started off wanting to be The Clash, but quickly mutated into a stadium-rock outfit for disaffected teenagers, an area they still inhabit today.

This is My Truth Tell Me Yours does nothing to change this state of affairs; mostly mid-paced, with a great deal of rather hollow lyrical rhetoric and somewhat clichéd song structures. Session keyboardist Nick Nasmyth brought in a raft of vintage gear, principally a Hammond and a Wurlie piano, and makes reasonable use of them across the album, although it's interesting to note that the band's next effort featured a noticeably stripped-down sound, as they apparently felt that This is My Truth was a bit 'lush' in the production department. I've always been under the impression that the credit for 'Mellotron' meant exactly that, but going by the interview with producer Dave Eringa here, it seems they're samples.

Anyway, fake 'Tron on three tracks; the rather pretentiously-titled single, If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next has some nice 'Tron strings running through it, while the balladic You're Tender And You're Tired has a short arranged string part in the middle. The Manics also used a proper string section on the album, so Nasmyth was obviously going for a distinct 'feel' by using the pseudo-'Tron here. Album closer S.Y.M.M. (South Yorkshire Mass Murderer, apparently) has a background strings wash, with a slightly more upfront part on the second verse.

So; as a non-fan I'm really not in the right place to recommend this or otherwise, while the Mellotron use is OK but not stunning, or genuine. Interesting to note that 'Mellotron/Mellatron' manages to be spelled two different ways in the liner notes... Anyway, your choice, as ever.

Official site

Jasun Martz  (US)

Jasun Martz, 'The Pillory/The Battle'

The Pillory/The Battle  (2005,  148.02)  ***½

Battle 1 [Soundscapes/Choir/Mellotron]
Battle 2 [Contemporary Classical/Orchestral]
Battle 3 [Tribal/Prog Rock]
Battle 4 [Anarchy/Freeform/Percussion]
Battle 5 [Mellotron/Celestial Pipe Organ]
Battle 6 [Ambient]
Battle 7 [Industrial/Noise/Ambient]

Current availability:

In 2004, word started circulating of a follow-up to Martz's '78 avant-classic, The Pillory, finally released in 2005 as The Pillory/The Battle. Yours truly was asked to participate in the recording, along with many others, but sadly, didn't get his act together in time to contribute, or it may not have been necessary to put the review here. Mind you, I rather doubt whether the end result has been seriously compromised as a result... Stylistically, the album isn't a million miles away from the original Pillory, being largely dissonant modern classical, crossed with just plain 'weird'. Battle 3 lives up to its subtitle of 'Tribal/Prog Rock', with some (relatively) straightforward drumming and riffy guitar, overlaid with a killer violin solo by Benedict Brydern, while the disc-long Battle 7 is possibly the best piece on the album, including a ten-minute plus solo organ part.

Upon being asked directly, Jasun admitted that while the album featured 'Mellotron sounds', and while he has owned several 'Trons over the years, this time round there was no actual tape-replay involved. Apart from the fact that all too many current releases feature samples (damn you, M-Tron!), my suspicions were aroused for all the usual reasons: too clean, long, sustained notes, not enough real Mellotron 'feel'. Who'd have thought it was so difficult to sample a keyboard instrument properly? Anyway, the fake 'Tron parts vary in quality, though the 8-choir on Battle 5 is good enough to fool the ear, and the super-loud, distorted strings on Battle 1 (repeating on 7) are excellent.

So; while the overall feel of the album is subtly different to its predecessor (hardly surprisingly, given the 25-year gap), if you liked The Pillory, you stand a good chance of liking this. Just don't come looking for more full-on genuine 'Tron... Incidentally, Jasun has expressed his intention to produce the third album in the trilogy in ANOTHER 25 years, which by my reckoning makes it around 2030. Now, I'll be nearly 70 by then, and I'm sure Mr.Martz has a few years on me... Good luck, Jase!

Official site

La Maschera di Cera  (Italy)

La Maschera di Cera, 'In Concerto'

In Concerto  (2004,  78.40)  ****

Il Canto dell'Inverno
Il Grande Labirinto
Ai Confini del Mondo
Il Viaggio Nell'Oceano Capovolto Pt 1
La Maschera di Cera
Del Mio Mondo Che Crolla
el Mio Abisso e del Vuoto/Del Mio Volo

Current availability:

La Maschera di Cera's studio albums feature real Mellotron, but their 2004 live effort, In Concerto, clearly doesn't, as can be seen from the lack of anything Mellotronic in the booklet pics. The album itself is a good representation of the band live, warts'n'all; they seem to feature a 'garage prog' sound on stage, rough as hell, but very live. Bassist and bandleader Fabio Zuffanti plays the entire set through a fuzzbox, for reasons known best to himself (an attempt at a Ricky impersonation?), and what has to be a straight-from-the-desk recording has Agostino Macor's Roland monosynth (not sure which one) too high in the mix, but it's quite nice, for once, to know that what you're hearing is what was actually played on the night.

Macor's 'Mellotron' work goes to some lengths to sound genuine, so credit there, with sustained chords faded quickly out and back in, as you might with a real 'Tron. Plenty of strings, with bursts of choir and flutes here and there, source unknown, though they sound as good as any samples I've heard before. So; a raw-but-real live album, with the band taking chances (always good to hear), and plenty of fake 'Tron work, so pick this up if you see it at a decent price.

Official site

Mélia  (Québec)

Mélia, 'Certitudes'

Certitudes  (2005,  49.21)  ***

Je M'Incline
Entre Toi et le Vent
Perseides
Deux Printemps
Attends-Moi
Les Champs Brûler
Certitudes
Rien à Dire
Je T'Aime Je Crois
Fleuve

Current availability:

Essentially a duo of vocalist Claudia Côté and guitarist Stéphane Desbiens (Sense, Ère G), Mélia's debut, Certitudes, has garnered surprisingly few 'Net reviews for a three year-old album, probably because it isn't easily pigeonholed. Folk? Prog? 'Melodic rock'? All of the above? It starts off in a bright'n'breezy folk style, until the rockier Perseides, three tracks in, after which the rest of the record chops and changes between styles. You can see this as 'varied' or 'directionless', largely depending on whether your glass is half-full or half-empty, I suppose. My chief criticism is that it all starts sounding a little samey after a few tracks. Côté's voice is slightly bland, although perfectly 'nice' in an Annie Haslam kind of way, but without her distinctiveness, and Desbiens' electric guitar work is rather faceless, too.

'Mellotron', presumably from Desbiens, on opener Je M'Incline, with decent helpings of strings and choir throughout the rest of the album. I'm afraid M. Desbiens is known as a sample user round these parts, and it's all too easy to spot here; there's no dirt under its fingernails, some of the notes hold for too long, and it's all just a bit too smooth for its own good. I know there are several working Mellotrons in Québec, but it's a big place, and there's no good reason Desbiens should know any owners, but if you're going to fake it, try to keep it a bit lower in the mix; it's just all a bit too obvious here, but then there's a good argument to be made that 'it's just another colour in the instrumental palette, who cares if it's real?' Well, me actually, but who cares that I care?

Anyway, a decent enough record, although not very exciting, to be honest. Some nice moments, not least those involving the 'Tron samples, but not really world-class.

Mellow  (France)

Mellow, 'Perfect Colors'

Perfect Colors  (2004,  50.56)  ***

Perfect Colors
Fantastic
Love Ain't the Answer
Goodbye
Drifting Out of Sight
It Was Raining
Where Flowers Don't Grow
Between the Lines
Going Downtown
Out of Reach
In the Meantime
Drifting Out of Sight (orchestral version)
A Place for Meditation

Current availability:

Mellow's second album, Perfect Colors, is essentially a more insipid version of their debut (variously known as Another Mellow Winter, Another Mellow Summer and Another Mellow Spring), with most of its interesting bits removed. Any of the proggy excess shown on this album's predecessor have been ruthlessly excised, leaving a bunch of the modern equivalent of middling soft rock songs with little real individuality. It's not that the material is actually bad; it just isn't that good, either, and doesn't make this reviewer want to press the 'play' button again.

There seem to be a couple of major pointers towards the album's 'Mellotron' use being samples; nobody's credited with playing it, and the choirs on the semi-unlisted track, A Place For Meditation, are far too clean to be the real deal. Anyway, what we're left with are a couple of string chords on Where Flowers Don't Grow and the previously-mentioned choirs, though this time round, the flutes are all real. Anyway, if you liked Another Mellow..., don't automatically assume that you're going to get more of the same this time round, although some of you may like it anyway.

Mercury Rev  (US)

Mercury Rev, 'Deserter's Songs'

Deserter's Songs  (1998,  44.46)  ****

Holes
Tonite it Shows
Endlessly
I Collect Coins
Opus 40
Hudson Line
The Happy End (the Drunk Room)
Goddess on a Hiway
The Funny Bird
Pick Up if You're There
Delta Sun Bottleneck Stomp
Mercury Rev, 'All is Dream'

All is Dream  (2001,  49.47)  ****

The Dark is Rising
Tides of the Moon
Chains
Lincoln's Eyes
Nite and Fog
Little Rhymes
A Drop in Time
You're My Queen
Spiders and Flies
Hercules

Current availability:

Mercury Rev had been around for years, starting life as a vastly more abrasive proposition than the one into which they've mutated. Deserter's Songs has been reviewed extensively by people who understand the music a great deal better then I, so suffice to say, it's a sort of Appalachian folk/intelligent pop/singer-songwriter crossover thing, with great songs and a beautiful, relaxed sound. I know it's a cliché, but this is perfect late-night (nite?) music, with more than a touch of the Neil Youngs in the vocals, and almost Beatley arrangements in places. Another obvious reference is The Band, with Levon Helm guesting on one track.

There's no credit on the album for anything orchestral, although the strings on some tracks absolutely have to be. What is credited is both Mellotron and Chamberlin (strings only, apparently), played by three different band members; Jonathan Donahue (Chamberlin), Adam Snyder and Dave Fridmann, although a little bird tells me that when Snyder was confronted with a real Mellotron, his comment was along the lines of, "Oh, so that's what they look like", ergo, he'd never seen one before, ergo, everything on the album is samples. Various brass, flutes (some real) and woodwind instruments on many tracks, which are sometimes definite 'Tron samples (Holes) and sometimes not (Endlessly), although they all sound a bit suspect, and now we know why.

Three years on, and All is Dream carries on from where Deserter's Songs left off, with even more Neil Youngisms on the vocal front, and a more dramatic sound overall, and fewer, but longer tracks. Credited string players confuse the issue on the Mellotron front, although veteran producer and 'Tron user of old, Tony Visconti, is credited with Mellotron flutes on Spiders And Flies, which I find highly suspect; he's known for hating Mellotrons these days, so given the disinformation on their previous album, I think it's fairly safe to say these are samples. It appears that Dave Fridmann plays all other 'Tron' parts (almost certainly samples, then), not that there's many apparent; flutes on Little Rhymes, strings on Spiders And Flies alongside Visconti's upfront flutes, and strings on Hercules.

So; two great albums, despite the fake 'Tron. Buy them anyway. Excellent.

Official site

Metaphor  (US)

Metaphor, 'Starfooted'

Starfooted  (2000,  73.58)  ***½

Ladder From the Sky
Chaos With a Crown of Gold
Starfooted in a Garden of Cans
The Illusion of Flesh
In the Cave
Seed
The Bridal Chamber
Don't Sleep
Battle of the Archons
Assumption

Current availability:

Metaphor have been around since the early '90s, initially as a Genesis tribute band, before switching to writing their own material. It took them until 2000 to release their debut, Starfooted, but the wait seems to have been largely worthwhile, with the band's various prog influences melding into a (relatively) unified whole. I'm not so sure about the lyrics, mind you, which seem to be based around the Christian creation myth, although this isn't what I'd call a 'Christian' album, unlike, say, the dreadful Akacia. Despite an occasional slip into dreary neo-prog territory, most of the album is pretty inventive, with a good dose of melody thrown in (remember that?), although it is a little over-long; you don't actually have to fill that disc up, chaps...

Marc Spooner uses a variety of keyboard sounds, though whether any of the older ones are 'authentic' is difficult to say; the Mellotron definitely isn't, as was confirmed for me by a new band member. The giveaway (as with so many similar) is the amount of fake 'Tron used on the album (mostly strings, with bits of flute and choir). It seems to me that most bands using a real one will restrict its use, as too much can be overwhelming and swamp the mix. On the other hand, samples will usually sit nicely in a modern, stereo-reverbed mix, and as such are frequently wildly overused, often tipping well over the 8-second limit; a serious giveaway. Nonetheless, it's nice to hear it here, and their new guy assured me they'd be using real 'Tron on their next album. That came out two years ago, so I'll be doing a bit of research into the matter. (n.b. They didn't).

Should you buy Starfooted? While not 'classic' prog, it isn't at all bad, and I can't see too many aficionados being upset by it. Not bad, and looking forward to hearing their newer material.

Official site

Mona Lisa  (France)

Mona Lisa, 'De l'Ombre à la Lumière'

De l'Ombre à la Lumière  (1998,  56.43)  ***½

Captif de la Nuit
L'Échiquier de la Vie
Les Guerriers
Passions
Voyage Avec les Morts
Souvenirs
Quelque Part sur un Quai
Les Noces de Cendre
Comme un Songe

Current availability:

To my total lack of surprise, Mona Lisa's 1998 reformation album appears to contain (at best) sampled Mellotron, which may actually only be decent string samples that have a 'Tronlike quality when un-stringlike block chords are played. Somewhat more to my surprise, De l'Ombre à la Lumière is actually passably good, albeit overlong (so what's new?) and with too much filler (ditto). Even more than on their '70s material, they sound like Ange here, although Dominique le Guennec's theatrical (French language) vocal style makes for lazy comparisons. The material veers between the 'almost as good as they ever were' opener, Captif De La Nuit, through the better-than-you'd-expect ten-minute Voyage Avec Les Morts, complete with lengthy guitar solo, to some more average fare towards the end. Fake 'Tron strings on several tracks, which never really convince, though you can see how they could deceive the ear in places.

So; nowhere near their classic, 1977's Le Petit Violon de Monsieur Grégoire (****½), but a respectable enough album from a reformed band, given some of the competition. Incidentally, it seems that the band is essentially Le Guennec backed by the members of '90s French act Versailles, so there's little musical connection with the old outfit.

Official site

Moongarden  (Italy)

Moongarden, 'Brainstorm of Emptyness'

Brainstorm of Emptyness  (1995,  71.07)  **½

Sea Memories
Who's Wrong?
Sonya in Search of the Moon:
  Silver Tears
Gun Child
Is He Mommy's Little Monster?
Sonya in Search of the Moon:
  Alone in the Nightfield
Chrome Heart
Sonya in Search of the Moon: The Search
Sherylin's Mistake
Sonya in Search of the Moon: Moonman Return
The Losing Dawn

Current availability:

Moongarden's amusingly misspelt second effort, Brainstorm of Emptyness, starts off quite well, with a few minutes of laid-back progressiveness, until the whole band kicks in around the four-minute mark. Oh shit, it's Marillion. Actually, more IQ than Marillion, but poor neo-prog whichever way you look at it. To add insult to injury, the album is quite interminable, and would've been overlong at 40 minutes. It's not all bad; when the rhythm section quietens down and the guitarist picks up an acoustic, it's actually quite nice, as on the first two parts of Sonya In Search Of The Moon, but as soon as that herky-jerky bass riff starts again, my brain shuts down in a vain attempt not to be reminded of the horrors of the '80s.

Cristiano Roversi plays a good bit of fake 'Tron, (he's admitted it's samples), even though '95 is a bit early for such things (Vintage Keys module, methinks). Flutes some minutes into opener Sea Memories, with a major string part on Who's Wrong?, whiile the strings on Gun Child rip off Yes' Heart Of The Sunrise quite effectively, although the rest of the album's string work is pretty decent. The choirs don't sound right at all, to be honest, which is hardly surprising, although there's a nice part in Sonya In Search Of The Moon: Moonman Return.

This really is only worth the effort for the dedicated neo-progger, I suspect, although there's a fair bit of sampled 'Tron, too. Sorry chaps, unoriginal, overlong and boring. Incidentally, Roversi's other main project is Submarine Silence, whose eponymous 2002 album is a rather better effort, although given that its 'Mellotron' has also been found to be fake... I believe the two subsequent Moongarden albums are better than this one; more news if I get to hear them.

Official site

Neal Morse  (US)

Neal Morse, 'Neal Morse'

Neal Morse  (1999,  55.47)  ***

Living Out Loud
Lost Cause
Landslide
That Which Doesn't Kill Me
Everything is Wrong
Nowhere Fast
Emma
A Whole Nother Trip
  Bomb That Can't Explode
  Mr.Upside Down
  The Man Who Would Be King
  It's Alright
Neal Morse, 'Testimony'

Testimony  (2003,  123.43/137.22)  ***½

The Land of Beginning Again
Overture No.1
California Nights
Colder in the Sun
Sleeping Jesus
Interlude
The Prince of the Power of the Air
The Promise
Wasted Life
Overture No.2
Break of Day
Power in the Air
Somber Days
Long Story
It's All I Can Do
Transformation
Ready to Try
Sing it High
Moving in My Heart
I am Willing
In the Middle
The Storm Before the Calm
Oh, to Feel Him
God's Theme
Overture No.3
Rejoice
Oh Lord My God
God's Theme 2
The Land of Beginning Again
['Special edition' adds:
The Fang...Sings!
Tuesday Afternoon/Find My Way Back Home]
Neal Morse, 'One'

One  (2004,  79.57)  ***½

The Creation
  One Mind
  In a Perfect Light
  Where Are You?
  Reaching from the Heart

The Man's Gone
Author of Confusion
The Separated Man
  I'm in a Cage
  I am the Man
  The Man's Gone (reprise)
  Something Within Me Remembers

Cradle to the Grave
Help Me/The Spirit and the Flesh
Father of Forgiveness
Reunion
  No Separation
  Grand Finale
  Make Us One
Neal Morse, '?'

?  (2005,  56.30)  ***

Temple of the Living God
Another World
Outsider
Sweet Elation
In the Fire
Solid as the Sun
Glory of the Lord
Outside Looking in
12
Deliverance
Inside His Presence
Temple of the Living God

Current availability:

  • Neal Morse: Radiant (US)
  • Testimony/One/?: Inside Out/SPV

Neal Morse kicked off his solo career while still seemingly happily the leader of Spock's Beard, with his eponymous debut in 1999. Those expecting a Spock's carbon copy have come to the wrong place; sensibly, Morse took the opportunity to record material that may not have worked so well for the band, although the heartfelt/cheesy (delete according to taste) ballad Emma and the closing four-part epic, A Whole Nother Trip, could have fitted quite easily onto, say, V. Much of the remainder veers far too close to AOR for this listener's comfort, though Morse could (rightly) be accused of sailing far too close to the wind on this issue right through his career. The 'Mellotron' on the album is highly suspect, not least as Morse doesn't own one, and apart from the drums, the whole thing was recorded 'at my house', so I've finally taken the decision to move it here. Anyway, faint strings on Lost Cause, Landslide and Nowhere Fast, although nothing in its obvious home, A Whole Nother Trip. Morse followed it with It's Not Too Late two years later, which is apparently very mainstream pop/rock; no idea if there's any 'Mellotron', though.

Oh Christ... Exactly. Morse made his dramatic exit from Spock's in 2002, after 'hearing the word', i.e. becoming a full-on God-botherer. Now, I'm all for religious freedom (including, of course, the freedom to have none at all), but when a public figure suddenly starts ranting about having seen the light, then seemingly throws up their career, you have to wonder if what's happening isn't nearer to nervous breakdown than Damascene conversion (see: Rick Wakeman...). Looking back, I suppose we should've been expecting this; I haven't heard his Christmas CD, Merry Christmas From the Morse Family (thank you very much), but I'm told it's absolutely excruciating.

Musically, Testimony isn't that bad, although not a patch on the best 'Beard stuff (than again, nor are later 'Beard albums); its most irritating quality is the sickly lyrical content, with reams of 'I love God so much' stuff that can turn the stomach of the non-believer. I mean, Oh Lord My God? WHY does all 'Christian music' have such a restrictive lyrical palette? I suppose it's what defines it as 'Christian'... Whatever happened to singing about life, love, an' all that? Maybe they'd argue that since God apparently encompasses all of those things, that's exactly what they are doing. Sorry, but gimme real-life stuff or, in fact, anything but this. Ironically, Oh Lord My God is the point at which the largely anodyne second disc picks up, but there you go... I've seen online reviews (from non-Christians) that rate this as one of the best albums of 2003, Morse's best work ever, etc., but I'm afraid I really can't see it. I mean, it's quite good in places, but harmonically, Morse is a one-trick pony, and he pulls out his usual chordal stuff yet again; I suppose at least you know it's him.

There's a real string section all over the album, but in many places, that 'Tron sound comes leaking through the mix, although I know Morse uses samples at home (see the diary page on his website). Restrained string use on most of the highlighted tracks above, although it sounds like flutes on Sleeping Jesus and Wasted Life, and choir on several, including California Nights and Moving In My Heart, although the gospel choir (as in The Water from The Light) obfuscate the issue. It's more than possible that I've got it entirely wrong above, and it's on more, or less tracks than I've listed; real strings, synths and massed harmony vocals don't help, but there you go.

So; your potential enjoyment of Testimony rather depends on whether or not you a) are a Christian, b) aren't bothered by the lyrical content if you aren't, or c) can simply ignore it. I can usually get round dodgy lyrical content by simply not listening, but it's so overt here that it's impossible to ignore. It would seem that the medium really is the message in this case, and this is, as the title says, Morse's Christian testimony to the world. There are artists who manage to put their spiritual message across without beating you over the head with it (the wonderful King's X spring to mind), but Morse doesn't appear to be one of them, so although the music isn't bad, I have to say, approach with extreme caution.

The basis of Morse's concept for 2004's One appears to be what botherers refer to as a 'crisis of faith', which he overcame, of course, otherwise we might have been presented with an album with less puke-inducing lyrics. HOWEVER... I have to say that I found this a far easier listen than its predecessor, despite Morse's ongoing total obsession with an imaginary deity; maybe the lyrics are actually less all-consumingly barking? Not sure, but while the musical palette remains the same, I wasn't offended as I was with Testimony. Musically, Author Of Confusion resembles the heavier stuff Spock's do occasionally, before lurching into one of Morse's patented multi-vocal parts, although most of the tracks do that standard Morse thing - you know, just like later Spock's. Towards the end of the album, he uses a small string section in preference to the 'Tron', with a brass section on closer Reunion, but otherwise, it's business as usual, with sampled 'Tron choir and strings dipping in and out during the lengthy The Creation, what I take to be flutes on The Man's Gone, watery strings on Author Of Confusion and repeats of these throughout. The booklet pics show both a smaller Hammond and a MiniMoog, but no Mellotron, so I think I'm fairly safe in assuming sample use.

? has to have one of the most confusing titles I've seen in a while - you try searching for it on Google... It doesn't differ markedly from its predecessors, although it could be argued that it's slightly more musically diverse, notably Solid As The Sun, with its brass and programmed beats. Lyrically, there are absolutely no surprises at all, with Morse obviously having completely regained his faith in something that doesn't exist, writing about it with nauseating intensity. Jolly good... Why bleat on to us about it, though? Maybe some of us would like to hear your music without being preached to about this post-nervous breakdown drivel? Also, do you think, Mr. Morse, you could stop regurgitating your early albums? In a ten year-plus career, the essential difference between the thirteen (count 'em) albums of original material you've produced is largely only apparent to those immersed in the progressive genre, and even then, the similarities are far more obvious than the differences. At least this album comes in at under an hour, rather than filling the disc to capacity, as you do so often... Anyway, the usual 'Mellotron' strings/choirs/flutes combo on most tracks, sounding more and more like good, high-end samples to my ears.

So; buying these albums means you have a cast-iron constitution, or are a Christian. Spock's Beard fans should probably get them all, but only if they can ignore the lyrics - I'm serious. Musically, it's pretty much the same old same old, but there's an awful lot worse than Neal Morse doing Neal Morse again. Your choice.

Official site


previous pagenext page