Home
reviews
album list
Chris Bell
Belle & Sebastian
Bellman
Ben's Brother
Ben's Diapers
Bench Connection
Benedictum
Jay Bennett & Edward Burch
Marit Bergman
Jerry Berkers
Dan Bern
Patrick Bernard
Heidi Berry
Louis Bertignac
Besnard Lakes
Philippe Besombes
Besombes-Rizet
Better Than Ezra
Bettie Serveert


Bee Gees  (UK)  see:

Bee Gees

Beggars Opera  (UK)  see:

Beggars Opera

Belbury Poly  (UK)  see: Samples

Chris Bell  (US)

Chris Bell, 'I am the Cosmos'

I am the Cosmos  (1992, recorded 1973-75,  54.18)  ****/T½

I am the Cosmos
Better Save Yourself
Speed of Sound
Get Away
You and Your Sister
Make a Scene
Look Up
I Got Kinda Lost
There Was a Light
Fight at the Table
I Don't Know
Though I Know She Lies
I am the Cosmos (slow version)
You and Your Sister (country version)
You and Your Sister (acoustic version)

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Chris Bell left Big Star after their seminal #1 Record and after various false starts, recorded the material that eventually became I am the Cosmos over a period of several years, in various locations worldwide, including Heureville (France), London and Memphis. Most of the songs are every bit as good as you'd expect from a Big Star songwriter, although a couple of the rockier numbers are slightly unnecessary. Highlights include the title track, the fantastic, slow-burning Better Save Yourself and Look Up, though there's very little wrong with most of the tracks.

The Mellotron isn't credited, and I don't know where the relevant tracks were recorded, but it seems likely that bassist/organist Ken Woodley's the guilty party. The original version of You And Your Sister has a brief 'Tron flute melody, although I can't tell whether the cellos are real or tape replay. The 'country version' added to the end of the disc has a major strings presence, while the fabulous Look Up heavily features the flutes again. As with Big Star, the Mellotron use is sparse and uncredited, but it's still well worth hearing.

Tragically, after several attempts to reform Big Star came to nothing, Bell died in a car accident in December 1978. It took his brother David nearly 14 years to compile this album, but it was worth the wait. I wouldn't buy it for the Mellotron, but for Beach Boys/Beatles-style clever, intelligent pop, it's as essential as the first two Big Star albums. Buy.

See: Big Star

Belle & Sebastian  (UK)

Belle & Sebastian: 'The Boy With the Arab Strap'

The Boy With the Arab Strap  (1998,  45.21)  ***/T

It Could Have Been a Brilliant Career
Sleep the Clock Around
Is it Wicked Not to Care?
Ease Your Feet in the Sea
A Summer Wasting
Seymour Stein
A Space Boy Dream
Dirty Dream Number Two
The Boy With the Arab Strap
Chickfactor
Simple Things
The Rollercoaster Ride
Belle & Sebastian, 'Legal Man'

Legal Man  (2000,  9.27)  ***/½

Legal Man
Judy is a Dick Slap
Winter Wooskie
Belle & Sebastian: 'Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like a Peasant'

Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like a Peasant  (2000,  40.53)  ***½/TT½

I Fought in a War
The Model
Beyond This Sunrise
Waiting for the Moon to Rise

Don't Leave the Light on, Baby
The Wrong Girl
The Chalet Lines
Nice Day for a Sulk
Woman's Realm
Family Tree
There's Too Much Love
Belle & Sebastian: 'Storytelling'

Storytelling  (2002,  35.28)  ***/½

Fiction
Freak
Dialogue: Conan, Early Letterman
Fuck This Shit
Night Walk
Dialogue: Jersey's Where it's At
Black and White Unite
Consuelo
Dialogue: Toby
Storytelling
Dialogue: Class Rank
I Don't Want to Play Football
Consuelo Leaving
Wandering Alone
Dialogue: Mandingo Cliche
Scooby Driver
Fiction Reprise
Big John Shaft

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

Belle & Sebastian (named after a French TV cartoon) are possibly the most fey band to come out of Scotland, and they're up against pretty strong competition. I'm not sure exactly when they discovered the delights of the Mellotron, but to my knowledge, they first used one on The Boy With the Arab Strap, named in honour of their friends, fellow Scots Arab Strap, in turn named in honour of an obscure sex aid. That's nice, then. I presume it's keyboard player Chris Geddes on the 'Tron, although they don't credit it on any of their albums. All I can hear here is a nice flute part (alongside real strings, by the sound of it) on Chickfactor, but one track doth not a 'Tron album make.

Several singles and EPs appeared before their next album, although the only 'Tron track I've been able to trace is Winter Wooskie (aargh!), from their Legal Man EP. A short flute part in a short song; very pleasant, but rather unexceptional. However, it's all over Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like a Peasant (those titles!). It's just a shame it's all so unbearably twee, really; they could be a nice Nick Drake-ish outfit if they chose. As for the Mellotron, apart from the real strings, there are flute melodies on The Model and Waiting For The Moon To Rise, and a chordal strings part on Beyond This Sunrise. Some marvellous chordal flutes enliven the 'how much more fey could they be?' Nice Day For A Sulk, although the solo flute on Family Tree sounds real to my ears.

Storytelling is a sort-of film soundtrack to Todd Solondz's film of the same name, although many of the tracks never got used in the final cut. Anyway, it's still recognisably Belle & Sebastian, adding a surreal element to the mix by incorporating several short 'dialogue' tracks, presumably from the film. There are a couple of more upbeat numbers, too, although much of the album sticks to their tried and trusted formula. This time, practically no Mellotron, although the strings on Freak have to be, although I don't know about the flutes.

So; three extremely fey albums, although if you like the quieter end of UK indie, you may well go for this stuff. Fold Your Hands Child... is the only one that's worth it for the Mellotron, though. More news if I get to hear all their non-album tracks from the period, although there's nothing on 2003's Dear Catastrophe Waitress.

Official site

Bellman  (Norway)

Bellman, 'Mainly Mute'

Mainly Mute  (2009,  49.08)  **½/TT

This is Life
Spaceship, Move Slow!
Lost My Way
Swimsuit in May
Sculpt Me a Dream

Celestine
Sleep Forever
All That is Beautiful
Requiem
Andrew

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Norway's Arne Johan "Bellman" Rauan seems to be named in honour of a peculiarly Scandinavian joke-form, akin to various other worldwide forms, not least the Irish/Kerryman/Polack 'harmless idiot' variety. On his debut album, 2009's Mainly Mute, he's opted to combine dreamy, vaguely chamber pop with post-rock, which might possibly turn out not to've been a good idea; I'm sure his intention was to produce an album of transcendental beauty, or somesuch, but the end result is an overlong, dreary effort, suffused with Rauan's strange, high voice that convinced me it was female until I learned otherwise.

Pål-André Rauan plays Mellotron on three tracks, with a melodic flute part, deep in the mix, on Swimsuit In May, while Sculpt Me A Dream opens with upfront, 'wobbly enough to be real' flutes and we get another majorish flute part on All That Is Beautiful. Overall, while not terrible, this is pretty dull fare, unless, I presume, you should be into this particular brand of indie. Fairly decent Mellotron work, but that's about it.

Official site

Ben's Brother  (UK)

Ben's Brother, 'Battling Giants'

Battling Giants  (2009,  46.54)  */½

Apologise
If I Let the Ladder Down
Stalemate
Battling Giants
Questions & Answers
Therapy
She is Love
What if I?
All Played Out
Should I Believe You?
Interlude
Bitter End
Letters

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Jamie Hartman has written pop hits for several currently popular artists, so it's no surprise that his band, Ben's Brother's second album, 2009's Battling Giants, features cameos from the likes of Joss Stone (poor man's Aretha) and the horrible Jason Mraz. The album itself consists of the wettest, most insipid kind of lightweight indie you can imagine; even the vaguest notion of any 'best tracks' is laughable, or would be if this wasn't so appalling.

Hartman and Nikolaj Torp play Mellotron, with a quiet flute part on closer Letters that can't have taken two people to play, although the album's various string parts sound real. This really is vile; the kind of music that's tailor-made for use in drippy TV programmes involving people feeling bad about nothing in particular. Another thing: what a truly, truly terrible sleeve. OK, we're not quite in the realms of Paul Simon's offensive-to-the-eye Surprise, but it's still complete 'artistic' drivel. An all-round shitter, then.

Official site

Ben's Diapers  (Finland)

Ben's Diapers, 'Laughter Tracks'

Laughter Tracks  (2003,  35.02)  ***½/T

Happy Man
Skylight
The Way it's Going to Be for the
  Rest of Our Lives
Sweet Somethings
I Wrote a Song About Sadness
Hey Rock and Roll
Josephine Geraldine
Huge in Heaven
Play Through the Rain
Under the Surface
Stockholm Sky

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

If I didn't know better, I'd have said that Ben's Diapers were American; I'm sure experts in the genre could probably nail them down to their hometown. Music? Americana. Vocalists' accents? Pure American. Even their name. Saying that, they're really rather good at it, and are probably the best American band in Finland. Stylistically, they seem to cover all bases, from the balladry of The Way It's Going To Be For The Rest Of Our Lives, the country-rock of I Wrote A Song About Sadness or the proper Americana of Happy Man.

Mellotron on one track only, played by Finnish owner Tom Hakava, with a 'classic' flute part (you know, 'Strawberry Fields') on Stockholm Sky, although that's it, it seems. Nothing on their latest release, Little Pilgrims (***½), sadly, but both albums are worth hearing if you're into the genre.

Official site

Bench Connection  (UK)

Bench Connection, 'Around the House in 80 Days'

Around the House in 80 Days  (2007,  50.22)  *½/0

Young at Last
Stainless
The Big Wide Out There
Rusty Money
Parting Shot
I'm So Blue I'm Black
All Strings Attached (Happiness Runs)
Last Needle in the Haystack
Saint Want
First Man Standing
Grandeur Fever
Vacuum Dreamer

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

The Bench Connection are the duo of Matt Deighton (Mother Earth, some other drivel), making him rather older than expected and Chris Sheehan, whose debut, 2007's Around the House in 80 Days, is a slushy, wet-as-water so-called 'folk' effort, horribly reminiscent of the worst West Coast nonsense you can imagine. Think: lots of tambourines. Does it have any 'best tracks'? No, it does not.

Mike(y) Rowe is credited with keyboards, including Mellotron, on several tracks, but the only two possible appearances, both on Saint Want, turn out to be real strings and flute. Oh well, there go another fifty minutes of my life, with not even a genuine Mellotron sighting to show for it. Pointless.

MySpace

Benedictum  (US)

Benedictum, 'Uncreation'

Uncreation  (2006,  53.24)  **½/T½

Uncreation
Benedictum
#4
Misogyny
Ashes to Ashes
Wicca
Heaven and Hell

Them
Two Steps to the Sun
Valkyrie Rising
The Mob Rules

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Benedictum are an American metal band with an unhealthy obsession with Ronnie James Dio and his works, it seems. Not only do several of the band double in a Dio tribute act, but two of Dio's former associates (Jimmy Bain and Craig Goldy) guest on their debut album, 2006's Uncreation, on which they cover not one, but two Dio-era Sabbath tracks to boot. OK, Dio is a God Of Metal, but TWO songs? And they tackled Rainbow In The Dark on an early demo... You wouldn't know it from listening to this album, but Benedictum boast a female singer, Veronica Freeman, clearly not a woman of the ultra-feminist persuasion, by the looks of her stage garb. She gets a whole picture gallery to herself on their website and... Yup, there it is: the obligatory near-soft porn shot [sigh].

None of which has much to do with the album. Well, it's a typical modern metal release, in that it combines 'classic' metal with relentless double-kick work, downtuning and near-ambient keyboard work. Near-ambient keyboard? Chris Morgan adds lashings of tasteful synths to the album, eschewing flash for atmosphere, in a welcome move from which many of their contemporaries would do well to learn. It's not actually a bad album, but, keyboard work aside, it's about as unoriginal as you'd expect of a modern metal album, and the Dio influence does them few favours.

Dokken's Jeff Pilson's production almost certainly explains Morgan's Mellotron use (he also shoehorned one onto albums by War & Peace and Lynch/Pilson), although it seems to be buried in the mix in places; are those 'Tron strings in the background on #4? Or choirs on Misogyny? Definitely strings at the end of the latter, with solo cello underneath, although I'm not totally convinced it's genuine... There's a shot of Pilson at a generic modern keyboard in the studio on their website, but that means nothing. Anyway, choirs on Wicca and Valkyrie Rising, with strings on Sabbath's Heaven And Hell, although you can hear the real thing do the same on 1982's Live Evil, boys'n'girls...

So; one for what I believe are now known as 'metalers' (ugh), although Black Sabbath/Dio fans probably won't want to bother. A couple of the band's own tracks have their moments, notably the lengthy Valkyrie Rising, but this isn't something to quicken the old-school hard rock fan's heart, nor that of anyone hoping to hear loads of Mellotron in a metal setting, real or otherwise.

Official site

Marco Benevento  (US)  see: Samples

Benevento/Russo Duo  (US)  see: Samples

Walter Benjamin  (UK)  see: Samples

Jay Bennett & Edward Burch  (US)

Jay Bennett & Edward Burch, 'The Palace at 4am (Part I)'

The Palace at 4am (Part I)  (2002,  70.19)  ***½/TTT½

Puzzle Heart
Talk to Me
Whispers or Screams
Shakin' Sugar
C.T.M.
Drinking on Your Dime
My Darlin'
No Church Tonite
Fireworks
Forgiven
Like a Photograph
Venus Stopped the Train
California

Little White Cottage
It Hurts

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Jay Bennett left Wilco after the problems surrounding the mixing sessions for their Yankee Hotel Foxtrot effort, teaming up with Edward Burch and recording The Palace at 4am (Part I) soon after. It's an intriguing mix of powerpop and the alt.country for which Wilco are known, with hints of '60s orchestral pop, making for a rich, detailed record. The material's good without being outstanding, better tracks including opener Puzzle Heart, the powerpop of Whispers Or Screams, No Church Tonite and lengthy near-ambient closer It Hurts. If the album has a fault, it's that old bugbear: length. Why make a 70-minute album? Once upon a time, the double-LP was a once-in-a-career option; now it seems to be standard. Too long, sir, too long.

Multi-instrumentalist Bennett plays Mellotron, amongst many other things, with a distant flute part on Talk To Me, murky strings on Shakin' Sugar and a few second of flutes at the end of C.T.M. There's a major flute part on Drinking On Your Dime, a distant one on My Darlin' and more obvious flutes and strings on No Church Tonite, with queasy string parts on Venus Stopped the Train and California (plus flutes) to finish things off nicely. At several points, the tapes sound like they're slipping, making it highly likely that we're talking real Mellotron here, which makes a nice change on a modern album, sad to say.

As a tragic postscript, Bennett died on May 24th, 2009, aged all of 45. Due to the iniquitous American system of health insurance (a major evil of the modern world, not least due to its international influence), he couldn't afford a hip replacement operation and died from an accidental overdose of painkillers. Thank you, free-market economics; chalk up another victim. Bennett apparently had several projects in the pipeline when he died, including a second volume of The Palace at 4am with Burch; we can only wonder how it might have turned out.

MySpace

See: Wilco

Marit Bergman  (Sweden)

Marit Bergman, 'Baby Dry Your Eye'

Baby Dry Your Eye  (2004,  46.43)  ***/½

Intro/Love for Sale
Tomorrow is Today
Adios Amigos
Can I Keep Him?
Shame on Me
I Will Always Be Your Soldier
Let's Just Fall in Love
Come Back and Haunt Me
Mystery
Place Your Bets
You're With Me
I Miss You
Outro

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Marit Bergman (ex-punk outfit Candysuck) makes upbeat pop/rock in the way that the Swedes seem to do so well (wasn't there a major Swedish pop group in the '70s?). Baby Dry Your Eye is her second solo album, a Swedish chart-topper, and while it would be easy to dismiss it as 'just another mainstream pop album', it's actually got rather more depth than that, particularly in the lyric department. I'm not saying it's going to appeal to the average Planet Mellotron reader, 'cos it isn't, just that it's better than you might expect.

Björn Yttling plays Mellotron on Mystery, but given that he's battling against clarinet, flügel horn and solo violin, it's rather hard to work out what he might be playing: background strings? Flutes? There's something going on well down in the mix, but I'll be buggered if I can work out what. So; the acceptable end of pop/rock, Swedish style. Better than bloody Roxette, anyway. No appreciable Mellotron use, however, although it would've fitted nicely (and audibly) onto two or three tracks here.

Official site

Jerry Berkers  (Netherlands)

Jerry Berkers, 'Unterwegs'

Unterwegs  (1972,  34.09)  **½/T

Jeder Tag Sieht Ganz Anders Aus
Glaub Mir, Susanne
Es Wird Morgen Vorbei Sein
Dafur Lebe ich Nur
Grauer Bettler
Ich Klage An
Gelobtes Land
Seltsam

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Dutch-born Jerry Berkers comes with impeccable krautrock/German prog credentials, having sung and played guitar and/or bass on Walter Wegmüller's Tarot and Sergius Golowin's legendary Lord Krishna von Goloka, not to mention being a member of Wallenstein on their first two albums. All of which makes his sole solo album, Unterwegs, all the more of an oddity, as it mixes mainstream pop/rock (the jaunty Glaub Mir, Susanne), Hammond-driven vaguely psych/prog (opener Jeder Tag Sieht Ganz Anders Aus, Gelobtes Land) and Euro-balladry (Ich Klage An, Seltsam) into a rather unappetising stew. It isn't all bad, admittedly, but there's little here to excite the Europhile proghead or krautrocker.

Mellotron on Dafur Lebe Ich Nur, with an unexpected brass part from his Wallenstein colleague Jürgen Dollase, though that seems to be your lot. So; a pretty unexciting album, to be honest, with one fairly unusual 'Tron track, should you feel so disposed.

See: Wallenstein | Walter Wegmüller | Sergius Golowin

Dan Bern (& the International Jewish Banking Conspiracy)  (US)

Dan Bern, 'New American Language'

New American Language  (2001,  60.05)  ***½/T½

Sweetness
New American Language
Alaska Highway
God Said No
Turning Over
Black Tornado
Albuquerque Lullaby
Tape
Honeydoo!
Toledo
Rice
Thanksgiving Day Parade

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Dan Bern's been known to joke that, "Bob Dylan was the Dan Bern of the '60s"; not arrogance, humorous observation. Bern's songs and style sound a lot like Bahb's, although his voice is a lot more tuneful (despite the great man's influence), but his welcome moratorium on modern equipment and production gives his albums a timeless feel, certainly compared to many of his just-predecessors' '80s shockers.

Bern has a handful of releases under the self-deprecating, ironic name "Dan Bern & the International Jewish Banking Conspiracy", including his fourth full album, 2001's New American Language. The material's reasonable, but as with so many singer-songwriters, the lyrics are probably regarded as being more important than their vehicle, making a couple of casual listens a little unfair. Wil Masisak plays Mellotron, amongst other 'boards, although the only obvious use is the excellently-played flutes and cellos throughout ten-minute closer Thanksgiving Day Parade, giving the album the unusual distinction of one-and-a-half Ts for just the one track.

There are two more Bern 'Tron releases, 2003's Fleeting Days and the following year's explicitly political My Country II EP, which I shall review when I get hold of copies. As far as New American Language is concerned, don't bother for the Mellotron, but it's a pretty decent album of Dylanesque songs for those into the style.

Official site

Patrick Bernard  (Québec)

Patrick Bernard, 'Exil'

Exil  (1982,  35.57)  ***½/TTT½

Un et Différent
Voir le Soleil
Le Lieu d'où l'on Ne Revient Pas

Intérieurs
Exil
Les Mendiants d'Amour
Le Véritable Ami
Le Père qui Regarde

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Patrick Bernard (he feels the need to say, "previously known as Bernhardt", on his site, for some reason) seems to specialise in 'devotional music', lyrically heavily influenced by his many years' study in India. It seems he was actually born in French colony Algeria, and has lived in various places, including France, Britain and Québec, although as he's settled in the latter, that's the nationality I shall list. Amusingly, the discography on his website lists nothing prior to 1989, after what the French Wikipedia describes (in translation) as his 'second mystical crisis'. Hmmm. So, New Age dreck, anyone? Anyway, 1982's Exil (actually his sixth album, it seems) opens with an early 'World'-type piece, Un Et Différent, before shifting into a pleasant, if undemanding kind of fairly straightforward slightly progressive rock, with a largish dose of French chanson thrown in, particularly noticeable on closer Le Père Qui Regarde; not a million miles away from the less proggy stuff Morse Code were doing a few years earlier, I'd say.

Plenty of Mellotron, apparently played by Bernard himself, with high string notes on Voir Le Soleil, making a template for the album's 'Tron use overall; a particularly good example is the opening to Les Mendiants D'Amour ('The Beggars of Love'), with a well-played melodic part before the more 'standard' chordal work later in the song. Cellos, for a change, at the beginning of Le Véritable Ami, alongside the more standard strings, so with only two songs being 'Tron-free, I'd say this is a surprise 'worth getting' album, assuming you can find a copy. Unavailable on CD, as Bernard isn't even acknowledging its existence, the only way I can see anyone putting it out is if the original record company decides there's any sort of demand for it; none of the specialist prog reissue labels will be interested, as it isn't 'progressive' enough. Is there a demand from Mellotron fans? Should I start 'Mellotron Records'? Don't even go there...

Official site

Heidi Berry  (UK)

Heidi Berry, 'Heidi Berry'

Heidi Berry  (1993,  46.34)  ***/½

Mercury
Little Fox
The Moon and the Sun
One-String Violin
Darling Companion
Distant Thunder
Heart Like a Wheel
For the Rose
Follow
Ariel
Dawn

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

American-born but British-raised makes Heidi Berry effectively a Brit (this logic is reversed in other places on this site), although her confessional singer-songwriter style is probably more transatlantic than home-grown, ironically. Her music, at least on her third, eponymous album, fits loosely into 4AD's 'house style' (think: Cocteau Twins), being laid back to the point of drifting, although it seems to have little of their appeal. Don't get me wrong; it's perfectly pleasant, but too undemanding to actually grab the listener's attention, although I'm sure there are plenty who would disagree.

Credited Mellotron on one track, Little Fox, from Robert Lord, but given that the track already features real strings, all I can hear is a faint background flute part that really wasn't worth recording. So; inoffensive but ineffectual, with next to no 'Tron. Next...

Official site?

Louis Bertignac  (France)

Louis Bertignac, 'Longtemps'

Longtemps  (2005,  41.14)  ***/½

Rêver d'L
Je Joue
Elle Pleure
Les Frôleuses
Audimat
La Saga des Gnous
Sous la Pluie
Sans Toi
J'Ai Pas l'Temps
Tant Pis pour Tout
Rendez-Vous là-Haut
Longtemps

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Algerian-born Louis Bertignac is a French singer-songwriter, once a member of both Shakin' Street and Téléphone, two of his country's premier late '70s outfits. Including the two albums he made with Bertignac et les Visiteurs, 2005's Longtemps is his sixth solo studio release, a perfectly acceptable vaguely roots-rock effort, although, as with so many similar, I'd imagine you'll get more out of it should you speak the language. It shifts between the expected rock-with-acoustic guitars through the ethnic-ish La Saga Des Gnous to the folk-blues of J'Ai Pas L'Temps and the straight folk of the title track, making for a decent level of stylistic variety on the kind of album that, all too often, is rather one-dimensional. Best track? My personal favourite is the lengthyish Longtemps itself, but only because it has a slight psych feel to it.

Johan Ledoux plays background Mellotron flute chords on J'Ai Pas L'Temps, albeit not to any great effect. This an unexpectedly decent singer-songwriterish effort, then, although non-French speakers should probably approach with caution.

Official site

Besnard Lakes  (Canada)

Besnard Lakes, 'The Besnard Lakes Are the Roaring Night'

The Besnard Lakes Are the Roaring Night  (2010,  46.33)  **½/T

Like the Ocean, Like the Innocent
  Pt.1: The Ocean
  Pt.2: The Innocent

Chicago Train
Albatross
Glass Printer
Land of Living Skies
  Pt.1: The Land
  Pt.2: The Living Skies/font>
And This is What We Call Progress
Light Up the Night
The Lonely Moan

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

The Besnard Lakes are the husband/wife team of Jace Lasek and Olga Goreas, who play a rather gloomy form of indie. On their third album, 2010's The Besnard Lakes Are the Roaring Night, they are toweringly unambitious, clearly content to make the most unimaginative music they can, er, imagine, waffling along for three-quarters of an hour, although it feels longer. The nearest the album gets to highpoints are two-part opener Like The Ocean, Like The Innocent, mainly due to their style having not yet become completely tedious and the slide guitar opening to Albatross, although it slumps into their default slough of despond all too soon.

Lasek and Goreas both play Mellotron, with uncredited flutes on part one of Land Of Living Skies, The Land, although both are credited with the strings on Light Up The Night. Do you like waif-like indie? Really? Well, you stand a good chance of going for this, then. I don't, so I'm more than happy never to have to hear this again. A little Mellotron, but really not enough to be worth the bother.

Official site

Philippe Besombes  (France)

Philippe Besombes, 'Cesi est Cela'

Ceci est Cela  (1979,  40.16/79.09)  ***/T

Princesse Lolita
Géant
Pawa 1
Ceci est Cela
Seul
[CD adds:
Traversée
Trio
L'or des Fous 4
L'or des Fous 2
PFJ 159
PJF 137]

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

After working with Jean-Louis Rizet on Pôle and making two albums with Hydravion, Philippe Besombes released Ceci est Cela in 1979, although there seems to be some dissent over not only its year of release, but even its title. Now-defunct Israeli label MIO reissued the album as a greatly-expanded CD, but misspelt its title Cesi est Cela and gave its year of release as 1979, although it may well be from 1976, pre-dating Hydravion. To add to the confusion, opening spoof disco number Princesse Lolita is sequenced in such a way that you have to wind back from the beginning of track 'one' to hear it at all. Once you get past that horror/joke/selling point, most of the album, unsurprisingly, largely consists of atonal electronic hums and squawks, although the odd tuneful bit sticks its head above the ramparts in paces. As with Pôle (below), this isn't an album for the faint-hearted, or the 'standard' EM fan (aren't these one and the same thing?).

Obvious Mellotron on one track only, with an ominous string part on Géant that forms the bedrock of the piece, and while it's possible that the screechy noises on a couple of other tracks are 'Tron-related, it seems unlikely. So; avant-EM. Isn't that how it should be? Borders listenable in places, to be honest, but one decent 'Tron track for the (should be) committed.

Besombes-Rizet  (France)

Besombes-Rizet, 'Pôle'

Pôle  (1975,  75.49)  ***½/TT½

Haute Pression
Evelyse
Armature Double
Lundi Matin
Montélimar
Rock à Montauban
Synthi Soit-il

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Philippe Besombes and Jean Louis Rizet were French experimental musicians who only properly collaborated once, on 1975's Pôle (named for the independent label on which it was released), a double album of electronic music, sometimes cited as the best French album in the genre. Despite superficial similarities, don't think Tangerine Dream here; Besombes-Rizet were far more percussive, and the music has a completely different feel - comparisons with another French electronic duo, Heldon, are more relevant. Much of the music spread across the album's four sides is quite harsh, albeit interesting; lush melodies and Mellotron soundscapes are notable by their absence, substituted by brittle synth work and manic percussion.

Philippe Besombes (?) at the Mellotron

I've really no idea who plays what here; a whole raft of gear was used, including Rhodes (principally on Evelyse), Mellotron M400, MiniMoog, ARP Odyssey and various EMS equipment, mostly to good effect, with several modular-sounding percussive patches finding their way onto various tracks. On the Mellotron front, Haute Pression features male choir throughout much of its length, plus a smattering of strings, but on the side-long Armature Double the duo go completely overboard, utilising Mellotron vibes and percussion, with some vicious tympani and tubular bell work (!), after a rich string intro. Montélimar only has a brief burst of strings on the intro, and that would seem to be your lot.

So; you're not going to find a vinyl original of this, and the excellent Israeli RIO label have gone under, so once their pressing of Pôle has sold out, it's gone. EM fans who wish to venture beyond their 'Berlin School' comfort zone or anyone who wants to hear Mellotron percussion used in anger would do well to invest in a copy while they still can.

Better Than Ezra  (US)

Better Than Ezra, 'How Does Your Garden Grow?'

How Does Your Garden Grow?  (1998,  58.26)  **/½

Je Ne M'en Souviens Pas
One More Murder
At the Stars
Like it Like That
Allison Foley
Under You
Live Again
Happy Day MāMā
Pull
Particle
Beautiful Mistake
Everything in 2's
New Kind of Low
  Low
  Coma

Waxing or Waning?

Current availability:

Chamberlin used:

Although they apparently started life as a proto-Americana outfit in the late '80s, by their fourth album, 1998's How Does Your Garden Grow?, Better Than Ezra had turned into a whiny indie act, with Kevin Griffin's vocals being particularly worthy of opprobrium. It's saying something when a song as weak as the two-part New Kind Of Low can be hailed as the album's highlight, although its first part, Low, provides a much-needed burst of energy just when you'd given up all hope.

Griffin is credited with Chamberlin, spelt properly for once (hurrah!), but amongst a cluttered production, with real strings and something called a 'metasynth', the only places it's at all obvious are a rude outburst of brass in the middle of Happy Day MāMā (dunno why the accents) and a brief flute part (possibly a rhythm track?) at the beginning of the next song, Pull. As a result, this is worth it for neither the music nor the Chamby. Avoid.

Official site

Bettie Serveert  (Netherlands)

Bettie Serveert, 'Lamprey'

Lamprey  (1995,  49.27)  ***/T

Keepsake
Ray Ray Rain
D. Feathers
Re-Feel-it
21 Days
Cybor*D
Tell Me, Sad
Crutches
Something So Wild
Totally Freaked Out
Silent Spring

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Bettie Serveert ('Bettie serves', from a Dutch TV show) coalesced properly in 1990, after a failed dry-run in the mid-'80s. Although usually described as 'indie', their sound, at least on their second album, 1995's Lamprey, has more than a touch of the Neil Youngs about it, if you can imagine a female-voiced Neil transplanted to 1990s Holland. It's actually pretty good, particularly opener Keepsake, although a bit of dead wood could've been trimmed with no ill-effects.

One (uncredited) Mellotron track, with flutes and strings on D. Feathers from drummer Berend Dubbe, to reasonable if not earth-shattering effect. Incidentally, Mr. Dubbe left after their fourth album and has gone on to form the retro- and Mellotron-happy Bauer. So; Lamprey: much better than expected, if slightly overlong and not really worth it for its 'Tron input.

Official site

See: Bauer


previous pagenext page