![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Highlighting in album tracklistings denotes 'contains Mellotron'. On 'multi-part' tracks I've tried to indicate which parts contain 'Tron, although this isn't always possible.
Ratings:
The * rating (½-5) is my personal, entirely subjective and completely partisan rating of the music.
The 'T' ('Tron, of course...) rating (0-5) is an only slightly more objective indicator of an album's Mellotronness.
By the way, if you know of any Mellotron albums that aren't listed here, please look at my albums page first! Thanks.
![]() |
Magazine (1976/78, 38.31) ***/THeartlessDevil Delight Just the Wine Without You Magazine Here Song Mother Earth Blues (live) I've Got the Music in Me (live) |
![]() |
Little Queen (1977, 39.00) ***/½ |
|
| Barracuda Love Alive Sylvan Song Dream of the Archer Kick it Out Little Queen Treat Me Well Say Hello |
Cry to Me Go on Cry |
|
![]() |
Bébé le Strange (1980, 37.30) **½/TT |
|
| Bebe le Strange Down on Me Silver Wheels Break Rockin' Heaven Down Even it Up Strange Night Raised on You |
Pilot Sweet Darlin' |
|
![]() |
Jupiter's Darling (2004, 65.03/76.27) ****/T½ |
|
| Make Me Oldest Story in the World Things The Perfect Goodbye Enough Move on I Need the Rain |
I Give Up Vainglorious No Other Love Led to One Down the Nile I'm Fine Fallen Ones |
Lost Angel Hello Moonglow How Deep it Goes [Bonus tracks: Fallen Ones (unplugged) Fallen Ones (psycho mix) Fireflies and Stars] |
Current availability:
Heart came, er, Straight Outta Seattle in the mid-'70s, although it took them a full ten years to reach their full arena-filling potential. Fronted by the picturesque Wilson sisters, Ann and Nancy, Heart had a built-in advantage over many of their competitors due to the sisters' looks (sad but true). Their music at the time is probably best described as Zeppelin-lite; the band gave the Wilsons a chance to indulge their Zep fantasies on stage, although they never even remotely equalled the sheer innovative power of their mentors.
They debuted with the rather lightweight but perfectly pleasant Dreamboat Annie (***½), containing their classic Crazy On You, which pretty much set the template for their next several albums. After signing to a major, Heart's old label, Mushroom, did the dirty on them, rush-releasing a bunch of demos and live tracks as Magazine in late '76. It's actually not a bad album, if not exactly what the band had planned, with Devil Delight standing out as a slow-burning rocker, and a decent ballad in Here Song, recorded as early as 1973. Credited Mellotron on one track, with a Howard Leese orchestrated flute part alongside real strings on Just The Wine, although it sounds a lot like 'Tron choir on their rather unnecessary version of Nilsson's version of Badfinger's Without You, and, despite a credit for real strings, the chords towards the end of the title track have that 'Tronnic quality about them. Heart took Mushroom to court and won, forcing a band-approved remix that cleaned up some of the sheer sloppiness of the original release, reappearing in '78, which is the version you're most likely to find.
Second album proper Little Queen isn't exactly what you'd call a 'Mellotron Album'; there's a tiny bit of mixed-back choir on rocky opener Barracuda, and despite being listed in the credits, any 'Tron there may be on the Battle Of Evermore-alike Dream Of The Archer (segued from the gorgeous Sylvan Song) is totally inaudible, even through headphones. Not a bad album, but Heart seemed to have considerable trouble transferring their live energy (listen to bootlegs from the period) onto tape, making their studio albums sound rather anodyne.
Two official releases later, Heart recorded their Mellotron again, managing to record one of the most innovative bits of 'Tron work I've ever heard, which just shows that you never can tell... Bébé le Strange's Down On Me has probably the best Mellotron pitchbending you're ever likely to hear; Nancy gives it her all on the pitch control, sliding string chords up and down and generally making the machine sound like nobody much else. After this tour de force, Heart never recorded their 'Tron again, making this one-off all the more odd; I'll never know why they didn't use it on their most Zep-esque number, the storming Mistral Wind from Dog and Butterfly (***½) (there's a killer live version on the full-length Greatest Hits/Live double), but there you go.
Over two decades later, Heart's first new studio album for 11 years, Jupiter's Darling, is a glorious return to form for the Wilsons, and a million miles away from their '80s AOR horrors (note the return of their original logo). More than anything, this reminds me of their first two albums, with shedloads of acoustic guitar, with the more rocking material actually being more convincing than almost anything they recorded in the late '70s. Ann's voice still has 'that' edge to it, making you feel she could burst into Dreamboat Annie at any second, and the consistency of the material puts even their best early work to shame. Craig Bartock plays Mellotron (do the band still own theirs?) on two tracks, with in-yer-face flutes and an unidentified string sound on Enough, with more flutes on Lost Angel. Welcome back, ladies.
So; for 'Tron work, Little Queen's a complete waste of space, but Bébé le Strange is interesting, if not a great album (my opinion, of course...), and Jupiter's Darling is worth hearing. Buy them if you see them cheap. I did...
![]() |
The Wonder of it All (1974, 35.36) ***/TThe Wonder of it AllHouse of Living Pass Me By Shine on Eight Hours Time I've Just Fallen Racin' the Sun LaFayette County |
Current availability:
Heartsfield were a six-piece countryish-rock band, and would quite possibly now be referred to as 'Americana'. Going by their second album (of four), The Wonder of it All, they were actually very good at it, having a slight CSN&Y vibe in places, specifically with regard to the vocal harmonies, although side two gets a bit countryish for my tastes. The best track (to my ears) is Shine On, with a more interesting chord sequence than the rest of their material, although Racin' The Sun is easily the album's longest track, allowing the band to stretch out a little.
Drummer Artie Baldacci doubled on piano and Mellotron, surprisingly, with a rich 'Tron strings part on Shine On, and some brief background flutes on Racin' The Sun, although this isn't exactly what you'd call an indispensable Mellotron album. If that laid-back '70s country-rock thing falls into your listening orbit, you could actually do a lot worse than this (it's now available on CD), although I've no idea what their other albums were like. Anyway, one decent 'Tron track, and the music's good for what it is. Better than the Eagles.
![]() |
Pleasure One (1986, 40.36) *½/TContendersTrouble Somebody If I Were You Low Society Red Look at Me Move Out Free |
Current availability:
Sheffield's Heaven 17 (or Seventeen), named for a fictional band in A Clockwork Orange, formed out of the B.E.F. (British Electric Foundation), who in turn, were composed of refugees from The Human League. Confused? After their initial burst of innovative synth-pop, characterised by singles like (We Don't Need This) Fascist Groove Thang and Temptation, they sunk into a mediocre premature middle-age, producing albums of averageness like their fourth, Pleasure One. This is basically '80s funk/pop-by-numbers, with none of the charm of their early work, perfectly content to trundle along in a funk-lite vein, without bothering overmuch about the songs. Harsh? Yup, but this was a really painful listen, amongst a sea of painful listens. Everything's that's worst about '80s pop encapsulated in one album.
Almost uniquely amongst such albums, though, is Martyn Ware's Mellotron use. Not that it's what you'd call major; strings that may be 'Tron on Look At Me, and definite strings on closer Free, though little enough that this hovers between half and one T, so in a spirit of generosity, I've opted for the latter. Anyway, I didn't want to hear this album, and nor do you. Hardly any 'Tron, and the music's horrible. Avoid.
![]() |
Eurooppa (1981, 33.17) ***/TEurooppaVideorodeo Woyzeck Omassa Kotona Vieraantunut Sydänten Kaatopaikka Koira Ja Hänen Miehensä Uni 8? |
![]() |
Yhtenä Iltana... (1990, 49.12) ***/TT½ |
|
| Yhtenä Iltana Juodaan Viinaa Halvat Pelit Seisovaa Ilmaa Väärät Naamat Näkemiin-Kuulemiin Älä Tee Sitä Amsterdam |
Minä Olin Hotelli Illat Pitenee Markan Valheet Sataako Huomenna, Padam Näin on |
|
![]() |
Salaisuuksien Talo (1994, 49.39) ***/TT½ |
|
| Viimeinen Unelma Velisurmaaja Tuuleen Magdaleena Joki Tulvii Kaksi Palaa Aameneen Salaisuuksien Talo Oisinpa Tuuli |
Tönkkösuolattu Kansa Joskus Itkee Jokainen Uskotko Ihmeisiin |
|
![]() |
Ei Selityksiä (2004, 51.46) ***/TT |
|
| Olishan se Hienoo Stadille Hysteeri Kuunnellaan Vaan Taivasta Ei Selityksiä Saarnaaja Nuorallatanssija Neljä Tuulta |
Juodaan Viinaa Lähes Onnellinen Mies Eki-Setä Tää on se Aamu Kun Rakkaus Saapuu Kaupunkiin |
|
Hector, known to his mum as Heikki Veikko Harma, has been active in the Finnish music biz since his first single in 1965, and has released over 20 albums since his long-playing debut in 1972. I've seen comments like "...influenced by David Bowie", probably referring to his early-'70s work, but his tenth album, 1981's Eurooppa, is a fairly mainstream pop/rock album of its time. All but one of the songs are by the man himself, although Sydänten Kaatopaikka is a Finnish-language cover of Short And Sweet from David Gilmour's magnificent eponymous solo album, carrying on what appears to be a long tradition of Finnish artists covering foreign material with translated lyrics, even if (as this case) the title bears no relation to the original. Mellotron from Finland's No.1 'Tronster, Esa Kotilainen (also on MiniMoog, ARP Omni and Oberheim OB-Xa), with choirs on the opening title track and strings on Woyzeck. It's possible there are a couple of other bits hidden away, but nothing obvious.
Hector's next relevant album is 1990's Yhtenä Iltana..., a folkier effort, at least going by the amount of the dreaded accordion to be heard on the record. Again, mostly self-written material, and while Seisovaa Ilmaa is better known as Walk On The Wild Side, I'm sure I don't remember any reference to Helsinki in the original. Kotilainen on Mellotron again, with choirs on the opening title track (again), a brief but lovely flute part on Näkemiin-Kuulemiin and background strings mirroring the Hammond on Älä Tee Sitä. More of those flutes on Illat Pitenee and Markan Valheet, and some really quite full-on flutes and strings on Sataako Huomenna, Padam, making this, against the odds, almost worth hearing for its 'Tron input.
Four years on, and Salaisuuksien Talo carries on in a similar vein, with rather too much accordion for my personal liking, mixed in with rockier numbers. By this point in his career, Hector seems to have settled into a kind of middle-aged singer-songwriter thing, with a rabid following in his home country, partly due to singing in his own language. Kotilainen plays Mellotron again, with flutes and strings on opener Viimeinen Unelma, choir swells on the rockier Velisurmaaja and more flutes on Joki Tulvii. Flutes again on the balladic Oisinpa Tuuli, alongside real strings, and flutes, low-end choirs and cellos on Joskus Itkee Jokainen, making for passable 'Tron input once again.
The last of Hector's Mellotron albums (at least to date), Ei Selityksiä, is more of the same, mixing more folk-influenced material with a few uptempo numbers, not least Hysteeri, which sounds a lot like that Ricky Martin hit, but isn't. Kotilainen's 'Tron work this time round consists of a few high string notes on opener Olishan Se Hienoo and a more straightforward part on the title track, although that's real strings on Kuunnellaan Vaan Taivasta. Background flutes and strings on Saarnaaja, with the same, but more upfront, on Eki-Setä, featuring the amusing lyric, "Eki-Setä has left the building".
It's actually hard to know how to rate these albums; they consist largely of mainstream pop/rock for whenever they were recorded, sung in a language spoken by few outside the country. Kudos for sticking to Finnish, although it may not be an entirely altruistic move, as I'm sure it's given Hector extra brownie points at home. Better to be a big fish in a small pond? Anyway, I've given them all three stars as none of them either offended or inspired me, and none of them seems particularly better than any of the others. Their Mellotron input varies, although I doubt if any of these are really worth tracking down just to hear some nicely-played 'Tron parts.
![]() |
II: Allez Teia (1975, 41.10) ***½/TTTIn the Wake of King FrippAphanasis Omar Diop Blondin Moebius Fluence Continuum Mobile Disjonction Inclusive St-Mikael Samstag am Abends Michel Ettori |
![]() |
III: "It's Always Rock'n'Roll" (1975, 83.08) ***/TICS MachiniqueCotes de Cachalot à la Psylocybine Méchamment Rock Cocaine Blues Aurore Virgin Swedish Blues Ocean Boogi Zind Destruction Doctor Bloodmoney |
![]() |
IV: Agneta Nilsson (1976, 50.22) ***½/½Perspective I (Où Comment Procéde le Nihilisme Actif)Perspective II Perspective III (Baader-Meinhof Blues) Intermède: Bassong Perspective IV Perspective IV Virgin Swedish Blues Psylocybine |
Current availability:
Now, far be it from me to say that Heldon mainman Richard Pinhas was a Crimson fanatic, but the title of his second album's opening track rather gives the game away. Assuming it wasn't some sort of Gallic joke, that is; I'm afraid it's rather hard to tell. Saying that, Heldon were by no means a straight Crimso copy; Pinhas had his own guitar technique that incorporated some of Fripp's stylings, rather than completely ripping him off. Given that both Pinhas and his collaborator Georges Grunblatt play Mellotron on Heldon II: Allez Teia, there is surprisingly little of it on the album; three tracks out of seven, to be precise. Think 'the quieter end of Crimso's improv scale', and you might be getting close to how Heldon used their 'Tron; strings, fairly dark, but drifting rather than intense. ...King Fripp is the best example on the album, but all three are worth a listen, as indeed is the whole album. I wouldn't call Allez Teia exactly startling, but it's a good listen with some unexpected twists.
Heldon III: "It's Always Rock'n'Roll" is an assault course of an album in many ways; a double LP of almost rhythmless electronics and general weirdness that makes its predecessor sound fairly normal. It opens with a purely electronic piece, ICS Machinique, following on with more synths and Pinhas' still quite extraordinarily Fripp-like guitar on Cotes De Cachalot À La Psylocybine, then proceeds in similar fashion for the next hour plus. Pinhas' Mellotron finally makes an appearance with some understated cellos on Virgin Swedish Blues (guess what: it isn't), while Grunblatt contributes the album's only serious 'Tron with a ghostly string part that ebbs and flows throughout Ocean Boogi (guess what: it isn't either). It could easily have fitted into several other tracks without disturbing the album's equilibrium, but the musicians concerned presumably felt otherwise. Pity.
Heldon IV: Agneta Nilsson contains four tracks of the by-now familiar electronic grunting, to greater or lesser effect, until the side-long Perspective IV, when Heldon suddenly turn into a full band. Bassist Alain Bellaiche and drummer Coco Roussel (later of the mighty Happy the Man, fact fans) jam away on the 20-odd minute track, alongside Patrick Gauthier on MiniMoog and Pinhas throwing some hitherto-unseen blues-rock shapes on Part 2, also titled Virgin Swedish Blues (guess what: it actually is this time). The track ends with a sudden tape cut; who knows how much longer they actually played? As far as the album's Mellotronic input goes, it seems it needed both Pinhas and a guesting Philibert Rossi to play the background string part on Perspective I, unless Pinhas contributed more of his almost-inaudible cellos; there certainly isn't any more obvious 'Tron to be heard on the record.
So; three albums of sometimes startling electronic experimentation (and I haven't even mentioned their bonkers debut, the 'Tronless Électronique Guérilla). Allez Teia is probably the only one actually worth buying for its 'Tron use, though, despite one decent track on "It's Always Rock'n'Roll".
![]() |
End of Illusion (1982, 42.41) ***½/0 |
|
| 7th Heaven Microwar The Fantasies Robot Village String Song Rising Mind Electronical Story End of Illusion |
Missinterpreted Omen Custom Thrill Amnesia Dancing Progressions for Computers Automatic Hammer Digital Anthem |
|
Current availability:
Anders Helmerson was a music student in the late '70s, effectively thrown out for expressing an interest in anything written later than 1900. According to the biography on his website, End of Illusion took three years to record, and disappeared without trace after a limited release on an unsuitable label in Sweden. It's good without being great, although the keyboard playing is absolutely faultless, with Helmerson attacking piano, organ and various mono- and polysynths and allegedly, Mellotron (stupendous piano work on Automatic Hammer, for example). His influences aren't too hard to spot, with plenty of Emersonian organ work, and a UK (the band) feel in places, although there's enough of him in it to rescue it from ignominious Triumvirat territory.
However... Unless my ears are really seriously deceiving me, there isn't a jot of Mellotron on the album. It's credited, and it may well be hidden away somewhere in the mix, but there aren't even any points at which you think, "Well, maybe there...". Zilch. Nada. Bugger all. So; not a bad album, with some good ensemble playing (plenty of guest musicians) and some fiery keyboard work, but zero 'Tron.
![]() |
Henry Fool (2001, 51.43) ****½/TTT |
|
| Friday Brown Bass Pig Poppy Q Lateshow Midnight Days Blindman One Poppy Z Blindman Two Grounded |
The Laughter That Turned to Ice Jazz Monkey Judy on the Brink The David Warner Wish List Heartattack The Mellow Moods of Malcolm McDowell Dreamer's Song Tuesday Weld |
|
Current availability:
Henry Fool are that rarest of things, a contemporary UK progressive act who don't want to be Marillion or It Bites. At long bloody last. Put together by No-Man main man Tim Bowness, they mix various influences together, coming on like a sort of Floyd/Radiohead thing with extra added ambient textures. Thankfully, Henry Fool is a million miles away from the whole British neo-prog thing, and is all the better for it, being probably the most 'out there' release on Malcolm Parker's Cyclops label. It's also an album that's ping-ponged between this page and the 'Sampledelica!' section, eventually finding its way back here again, for reasons detailed below.
The compositions ebb and flow, picking up speed here and there, particularly during the epic Lateshow, or the freeform jamming of The David Warner Wish List, though tending towards the mellow end of the spectrum. There's an almost late-night jazz feel to it in places, though that's not to say it's actually jazzy. Er, it's slightly difficult to describe, really... Stephen Bennett's Mellotron playing abounds (with a little help from Bowness), with much strings, and bits of flute and choir here and there; I'm reliably informed that it's a mixture of real and Roland JV1080 samples, presumably due to the contents of the real one's tape frame. Poppy Q would be especially recommended on the 'Tron front, except for the minor problem that the strings hold for far too long to be genuine, but Grounded (from Lateshow) and the major string part on Bass Pig are definite recommendations. Some of the Mellotronic textures here are just a little too smooth, giving their origin away, but it's nice to be able to confirm that at least some of it's the Real Deal.
So; a damn' good album, modern but with traditional touches. This is unlikely to upset either your dinner party guests or your prog mates (in the unlikely event of your having both); probably enhanced by 'relaxing' substances, though I wouldn't actually know. No, really. Wholeheartedly recommended for both music and real and fake 'Tron. Excellent.
![]() |
Farewell Aldebaran (1969, 34.47) ***½/T½ |
|
| Snowblind Horses on a Stick Lullaby St. Nicholas Hall Three Ravens Raider Mrs. Connor Rapture |
Charity Farewell Aldebaran |
|
Current availability:
Vocalist Judy Henske married folkie Jerry Yester of the Modern Folk Quartet, and later of the Lovin' Spoonful, in the early '60s, making the one-off Farewell Aldebaran in California at the end of the decade. Almost inevitably released on Frank Zappa's Straight imprint, it's almost impossible to categorise, although 'folk/psych' will probably have to do for now. Every track is essentially a different style, from the pseudo-sea shanty Raider through St. Nicholas Hall's satirical take on the Anglican hymnbook to the more straightforward folk-rock of Charity. Nobody much bought it at the time, probably due to its eclecticism, and even now, its availability seems to be due solely to a super-dodgy UK-based pirate outfit, Radioactive, who specialise in unauthorised reissues of overseas material (see: the Marshall Brothers Band), making potential lawsuits prohibitively expensive.
The reason this album's here is a couple of tracks featuring the Chamberlin. St. Nicholas Hall opens with a female voice that fools the listener into thinking it's real for a moment, until a pitch change alerts you to its keyboard origin. The male voices appear later (is this a keyboard split, or two sounds overdubbed?), making for one of the clearest recordings of the sound I've ever heard. More of the same, but less so, on the closing title track, along with some fantastic early Moog modular (belonging to Bernie Krause of Beaver & Krause, apparently), including an emulation of a vocoder, before such things actually existed.
This is a pretty strange record, it has to be said, but those of you with slightly more eclectic tastes may just go for it. Until/if an authorised issue appears, however, PLEASE don't buy this new, putting money into a pirate's pocket. Bootlegs of unreleased material are one thing, but ripping off official albums and the artists concerned is another. Bootleg the boots, and get someone to copy this for you. As far as its Chamberlin input's concerned, while interesting, it probably doesn't make it actually worth paying decent money for, but as I've just said, you don't want to do that anyway, do you?
![]() |
Tangled (1995, 43.52) ***/½ |
|
| Kill Another Day Blinded Backdated She Says She Knows The World Carry on Loving I Love the Things You Know I Don't Know |
Can't Explain Believe in Me Rollerblade The Breadwinner London She's Another Girl 1961 |
|
Current availability:
Anyone remember Haircut 100? Nick Heyward was their slightly unlikely heartthrob singer, though, let's face it, nowhere near as unlikely as ex-Undertone Feargal Sharkey... Seems he left the Haircuts as early as '83, after just one album, kicking off his sporadically successful solo career the same year, releasing his fifth solo effort, Tangled, in 1995. It's a major move away from that '80s pop sound, having more of a '60s influence about it, in line with the then-current Britpop movement, albeit without the naffness of Oasis et al, while still capturing some of that '90s zeitgeist. It's also not terribly exciting, but then, I don't think 'exciting' was where Heyward was coming from at the time, more 'well-crafted' and 'very listenable'. There's a surprising rockiness about several of the tracks, not least opener Kill Another Day and Carry On Loving, which would doubtless have appalled his jangly early-'80s self.
'Melatron' (aargh!) credited on one track, with Phil Taylor (not that one, stoopid) playing a faint flute part on London, but there's also uncredited flutes on Kill Another Day, that are actually more audible. Nothing to get too excited about, mind, but at least it's there... Heyward released another album with some 'Tron content, '98's The Apple Bed; as always, more news when I get to hear a copy. As far as Tangled goes, it's a perfectly acceptable '90s pop/rock album, which is vastly preferable to an '80s pop/rock album, but it's unlikely to blow you away on the singer-songwriter front. Not much 'Tron, either, but I've heard worse. Incidentally, Nick's elder brother, Pete, who has also worked as Nick's road manager, has been 'David Gilmour' in London Floyd tribute Pink Fraud (ho ho) for some years now, one of the best such efforts doing the rounds, also featuring Billy Surgeoner from The Mynd on keys.
![]() |
From the Playground (2002, 49.18) **½/T |
|
| Ambulance Chasers Two Tall Trees Remember (the Water) Weightless You Can Only Fall Breaking Down the Walls Gone |
I Go Low (the One You Thought You Knew) Revelations Genki Riders on the Line Out in the Longtime |
|
Current availability:
David Blazye, a.k.a. The High and Lonesome, is a serious young man from south London with a wispy beard, who seems to be under the impression that if he makes an album that sounds like the awful David Gray, or the quieter (quietest?) bits of Coldplay, he will be every bit as successful. Unfortunately, the success of these artists seems (to my ears, anyway) to be based less on their songwriting than on... I dunno, actually - what IS it based on? Image? Nope. Personality? NO! Sheer fluke? Maybe. Anyway, whatever it is they have, it would seem that Blazye doesn't, although From the Playground doesn't sound any worse to me than the debut efforts by the above-named artists. Maybe that's the problem - while exceedingly bland, maybe Blazye isn't quite bland enough.
Anyway, an album full of string-laden ballads is enough to send me off the deep end, so at least I'll (hopefully) never have to hear it again, although the pace does pick up just occasionally (Riders On The Line). Mellotron on Out In The Longtime from Tim Oliver, with an arpeggiated string line cropping up here and there, along with real strings, though hardly enough to make this worth buying. So; not very interesting, and low 'Tron content.
![]() |
12"/CDS (2000, 10.19) ***/TT I've Seen Some Things Hymn to the Boards Kelley's Heels |
![]() |
Beauty in Madness (2000, 46.30) ***/TT½ |
|
| Walks With Me I've Seen Some Things I Wait for You Letter Dime Motion Picture Scarecrow Jackdaw Never Said When |
Beauty in Madness When They Call Us in |
|
Current availability:
I believe Beauty in Madness is Scots quartet Hobotalk's first full album, although it was preceded by the I've Seen Some Things EP. They fall into the 'insipid pseudo-Americana' category, at least as far as I'm concerned; all country-inflected acoustic guitars and heartfelt lyrics about love and loss - you know the kind of thing. I usually like melancholy albums, but this one pushes the whole thing too far, almost into parody, in fact. It takes a lot to make me say this, but LIGHTEN UP, CHAPS!
Mellotron's credited on four tracks, largely played by Marc Pilley, although that's quite clearly 'Tron strings on opener Walks With Me, too. Of the credited tracks, Letter has cellos and flutes, while the only unidentifiable sound on Dime (I though these guys were Scottish?) is some muted brass that really doesn't sound like 'Tron. The title track has more flutes, played this time by guitarist Ross Edmond, and When They Call Us In finishes things off with some ultra-melancholy strings.
On the EP, the instrumental Hymn To The Boards is actually the nicest thing I've heard them play, with some spectral 'Tron strings over a quite beautiful melody, while Kelley's Heels has cellos and flutes over a rather less interesting song. Actually, while Beauty in Madness irritated the hell out of me, it has to be said that it's quite impeccably done; the Mellotron work's really quite nice, and used liberally, not just the 'faint flutes on one track' trick that you get so often. So, if folky Americana from Scotland's your bag, go for it.
![]() |
Megiddo (1997, 39.00) **½/TT |
|
| Blood Rock Star Lolita Fall Away Cold and Gray Hope You Don't Mind Strange Man Persephone |
Alive The Cannibal Ed Build a Home The Ashram Song |
|
Current availability:
Lauren Hoffman was an impossibly young twenty when she recorded her debut album, Megiddo, although she seems to've managed to avoid the usual clichés into which American (in particular) female performers of that age often fall. In other words, no Alanis or Fiona Apple tricks here. Unfortunately, unlike many other reviewers, I can't say I find her material that exciting, to the point where, although the album is under forty minutes long, I eventually found myself wishing it would finish just that bit sooner.
The inimitable Jon Brion plays Chamberlin on several tracks, with mixing engineer Ethan Johns chipping in on closer The Ashram Song. Blood has an effective string part, with a couple of seconds of solo male voice at the end (not a sound it's easy to miss...), while Lolita has what sounds to my ears like uncredited Chamby sax, and possibly cellos. I can't hear anything obvious on the single, the pointed Rock Star, or Cold And Gray, although it's definitely cellos on The Ashram Song, with a string part towards the end.
So; those of you with a bent for young female singer-songwriters (their music, their music...) may like this, but it's all a bit bland for my tastes, and I suspect many of you will agree. Not bad Chamby work, but not enough of it. Pass.
![]() |
Beyond the Galaxy (1999, 65.37) ****/TTTT½Beyond the GalaxyThe Gate of Lahore Part 1 Howling Wolves The Gate of Lahore Part 2 Wanderers of Time |
![]() |
Shiva Connection (2000, recorded 1977-99, 73.55) ***½/T½Shiva ConnectionInterstellar Rollercoaster Lightstar Rising Space Arbour A Few Miles Beyond Infinity Hi-Flyin' Shiva |
Current availability:
'Cosmic' Klaus Hoffmann-Hoock is a veteran of the electronic music scene, spending most of the '80s leading Mind Over Matter, who produced seven or eight albums, all apparently bursting with Mellotron. In fact, at one time or another, Klaus has owned at least 26 different 'Trons, of all models, although he now, unbelievably, owns none, preferring his multi-sampled 'Megatron'. However, his first album as Cosmic Hoffmann (that's very apt, Klaus!) features The Real Thing, with a nice picture on the back of him playing an M400.
Now, much as I like this area of the electronic scene, I find it difficult to review objectively, as I tend to use it as background music, and quickly get bored if I listen to it too closely. Saying that, Beyond the Galaxy is a fine album, indistinguishable (to my ears) from its '70s influences, and all the better for it. Most of the modern, computerised EM I've heard has quickly sent me to sleep, I'm afraid, but Klaus has produced a warm, organic album bursting with vitality and real playing. Remember that? Unlike some other practitioners of the art, there's no real dissonance here, but it's quite intense in places, so it's certainly not purely a chill-out experience, although it can work on that level too.
There's Mellotron all over the thing, of course. The lengthy title track doesn't feature any until about 12 minutes in, when the strings swell up in the loud section in their usual majestic fashion, carrying on into the subsequent lull. The Gate Of Lahore Part 1 is a gentle, rhythmless piece, with swathes of strings and flutes all over it, and Part 2 has some quite unique echoed strings that I haven't heard anyone else do in quite the same way. Howling Wolves is a more rhythmic piece, though slower than Beyond The Galaxy, with not only the rather ubiquitous strings, but some nice phased choir, too. Wanderers Of Time is the other lengthy piece contained herein, and is again relaxed and drifting, pretty much evoking its title in music, with loads more strings and the odd burst of flute chording.
The following year, Shiva Connection appeared, recorded in 1977, '94 and '99, meaning, I presume, that only the older tracks feature real 'Tron. The music is very similar to that on its predecessor, unsurprisingly, to the point where the uninitiated probably couldn't tell the two albums apart; not sure I can, tell the truth... The '77 track, Lightstar Rising, sounds pretty much exactly like those recorded over twenty years later, so at least you can't fault Klaus on the consistency front. The more recent material is co-written with Ramp's Stephen Parsick, a man known to use a Mellotron when he can get his hands on one, although I'm pretty sure the four newer tracks here utilise Klaus' Megatron, although the opening title track has no obvious recording details. Very little 'Tron, too, for that matter. As far as the older tracks go, Lightstar Rising has some distant flutes, while '94's A Few Miles Beyond Infinity has more of the same and a more overt string part towards the end of the piece.
Well, I don't really feel like I've really reviewed the music on these albums, to be honest, only their Mellotronic content, but if you're into this stuff to any degree, I can wholeheartedly recommend Beyond the Galaxy, although Shiva Connection seems to be less of the same.
![]() |
Hölderlin's Traum (1972, 34.44) ***½/TWaren WirPeter Strohhalm Requiem für Einen Wicht Erwachen Wetterbericht Traum |
![]() |
Hoelderlin (1975, 42.10) ***½/TTSchwebebahnI Love My Dog Honeypot Nürnberg Deathwatchbeetle |
Current availability:
Hölderlin, as they were originally known, released their first album, Hölderlin's Traum (that's, er, 'Hoelderlin's Dream'), in 1972, mixing folk influences into their fairly Germanic take on progressive rock, though this is not to confuse them with 'Krautrock', which is a different kettle of fish altogether. It's not a bad album - some would say a classic of the era; it certainly finds its own 'dark folk' style, well away from what most other bands were doing at the time. The only Mellotron, though, from Jochen Grumbkow, is on opener Waren Wir, kicking in along with the whole band after a typically gentle intro.
After considerable label hassles, it took the respelt Hoelderlin three years to follow their debut, finally producing their eponymous second album in 1975. A far rockier proposition than their first, Hoelderlin opens with the excellent Schwebebahn, with duelling viola (from Christoph Noppeney) and 'Tron strings (from the also respelt Joachim Grumbkow), which turns out to be the album's Mellotronic highlight. Honeypot has a few background string chords, and apart from what may possibly be some brass at the beginning, the 17-minute Deathwatchbeetle features only a short (but potent) string part towards the end.
I don't know of any other Mellotron use by the band, although I heard (unfounded) rumours of some on '78's Live Traumstadt. These are both good albums, though if you're not heavily into the 'German sound', I'd avoid their debut. Neither one's a Mellotron Classic, either, but they're both worth a listen.
![]() |
![]() |
Holding Pattern [a.k.a. Majestic] (1981/90, 28.53/77.10) ***½/TT |
|
| Another Point of View Honor Before Glory Jigsaw Dream Out of the Tunnels [CD adds: From the Clouds Majestic Iraqiroll |
Was it You? Mercenary Tunnels Arrival Around the Square Ten Passed Midnight Ground Zero] |
||
Current availability:
Holding Pattern were a late-period US prog outfit, led by guitarist Tony Spada, who released a self-titled mini-album in 1981, reissuing it on CD nearly a decade later, retitled Majestic and expanded to over an hour. The music on the original four-track release is instrumental guitar-led prog, less complex than many US bands, with Out Of The Tunnels being the standout track, bringing exemplary US proggers Happy the Man to mind. I don't know when the multifarious extra tracks on the CD were recorded, but they cover a variety of styles, with vocals on a handful, and a couple even recorded live.
Mark Tannenbaum played Mellotron, amongst other keys, with some epic string work on Honor Before Glory, underpinned by Taurus pedals, and a few background string chords on Out Of The Tunnels. Of the extra tracks, there's some 'Tron strings and choir on the gentle Was It You?, with some full-on choirs on the intro to Mercenary, though that would appear to be about it, despite some slightly 'Tronnish strings on a couple of other tracks. I've seen several rave reviews of this on the 'Net, but it's not really inventive enough to float my personal boat, although I've heard an awful lot worse. I believe Majestic (which came in an LP-sized case) is long unavailable, but apparently the four-track Holding Pattern has just been reissued. Weird. Anyway, not bad, so-so 'Tron.
![]() |
Brother Sun Sister Moon (2004, 51.02) ***/TTT½ |
|
| Summer Girl Gone With the Wind Same Way Again Daffodil Sky Miss U No Disco Kid Long as We're Together Don't Walk Away |
Without You in My Life Velvet Zone Hey You Love is the Answer It'll Be Alright Lost in Space Other Side of the Sky This is the Way Forward |
|
Current availability:
Christopher Holland is the younger brother of the irritatingly smug host of 'Later With Jools Holland' (late-night UK music show for non-residents), and grew up with his elder sibling's Squeeze colleagues wandering in and out of the family home. I have to say it shows in the songwriting on Brother Sun Sister Moon; classic British pop mixed with rather unnecessary white-boy funky stuff, which tends to spoil it a bit, unfortunately. The end result is an album that starts really nicely (Summer Girl is gorgeous), but quickly gets bogged down in rather dated mid-'70s mainstreamish stuff, which didn't sound particularly good at the time, to be honest. Holland's voice is a little bland, though serviceable enough and, as if to prove my point, rather better on the softer material. It seems the album was done on something of a budget - it sounds fine, but the sleeve looks like someone with little knowledge of graphics knocked it up on their home PC. Those fonts...
In a recent magazine interview, Holland mentions his love of 'classic' keyboards and indeed, Hammond, Rhodes and Moog (?) are all to be heard, as is the man's trusty Mellotron, which can be heard on about half of the tracks here. He favours the flutes, with several really upfront parts, although the strings crop up here and there, too. In case there was any doubt as to the machine's veracity, by the way, there's some obvious key-click on the flutes on a couple of tracks.
So; although Holland crams 16 tracks into 50 minutes, a few less attempts at funkiness would've made a nice, short album heavier on really good material. As it is, I can recommend maybe half the album, with the opening and closing tracks probably being the best. Reasonable.